Click Here for the rest of this issue
Socialist Party Home
No to private healthcare
Use the wealth for public health

The Socialist
"It’s worse [the Irish health service] than Baghdad was in the 1980s. I have never, ever had to treat a patient on the floor before, you know, somebody comes in out of an ambulance, they are really really sick, no trolleys, no chairs, I have to lie them on the floor on a blanket. I’ve never actually had to do that before. I’ve had to do it five times in the last year" - Dr Gerry Lane, Letterkenny General Hospital.

It is an astounding condemnation of the political establishment in this country that after 15 years of unprecedented economic growth the health service is worse than it was during the 1980s.

Alongside the crisis in the A&E departments and the numbers of patients suffering on trolleys, over 400 on some days, there are huge problems throughout the health service. Brendan Gleeson savaged the government on the Late Late Show and highlighted the degrading and obscene conditions that thousands of sick people have to endure in our A&E departments. His remarks were the catalyst that unleashed a wave of anger against the government forcing Mary Harney to declare a “national crisis” nine years after coming to power.

The new reviews and taskforces that are being initiated by the Health Service Executive (HSE) that start from the premise that there are enough resources will not solve the problems. They represent the latest attempt at arse covering by this government who have refused to deal with the core issues for years.

“You cannot deliver safe care to huge volumes of people when you don’t have the time, the space and the resources. You are constantly prioritising what is the next most important thing you have to do. You are dealing with high volumes of people and the danger here is the most urgent case might get missed because of the stress and strain that both the nurses and the department are under and that could be catastrophic for the patient. As a nurse in A&E it’s a real sickener listening to the HSE and the Tanaiste saying that things are getting better, that there are real improvements, and yet you have just left a completely overcrowded department with people waiting for their third or fourth day for a bed” - Joe Hoolan, A&E nurse Midlands.

Four thousand extra acute hospital beds and real investment in local primary health care could help resolve the A&E crisis. On top of this there are massive waiting lists for treatment and what are Mary Harney and this government focused on trying to introduce - a US style private health service! Of course if you have the money, you can get the best of care quickly with the minimum of fuss in the private health system, which operates like a leech on the public health system.

The counter-reforms that the government wants to implement, that is further privatisation - running health care on the basis of market mechanisms for profit, with increased charges for health care, will make the situation much worse. This government and their policies have completely failed.

The Socialist Party demands that the wealth that exists is used to establish a state of the art, comprehensive public health service that is available to all regardless of income. Such a health service should not be run by un-elected, un-representative quangos but should be run democratically by representatives of all healthcare workers and the broader community and on that basis could provide the type of health service we require.


Build all hospitals, schools and houses for no profit!
By Cillian Gillespie

There has been a lot of hype about the proposal by a private consortium to build the new national children’s hospital on a non-profit basis.

The media and politicians have heaped praise on the consortium’s so-called philanthropy and they claim it will save the state €250 million. In reality this offer harks back to the Victorian era when the poor depended on the crumbs from the tables of the rich.

The consortium is made up of a major building company, a property developer and Anglo-Irish bank. Yet this "benevolent act" exposes the massive profiteering that is going on in our society by construction companies, property developers and the banks, in fact the super-rich elite that make up this consortium.

It raises the obvious question how many more hospitals, schools, community facilities, affordable and social houses could we build if everything was built for people’s needs and not for profit!

It is profiteering by the construction industry and a massive decline in the construction of social housing by the government that lies behind the housing crisis. The cost of an average new house in Dublin is €330,000 yet according to insurance companies the rebuild value of an average house is only €100,000! So if all houses were built on a non-profit basis it would transform the lives of tens of thousands of people. Of course they won’t do this because these companies don’t build houses because people need somewhere to live – they build houses for profit.

There are ample resources within this society the problem lies with who owns and controls those resources. If you we had a socialist Ireland wherein everything was manufactured and constructed on a non-profit basis to meet the needs of people it would fundamentally transform this society and we could provide decent homes, schools and hospitals for all.