Click Here for the rest of this issue
Socialist Party Home
Housing crisis
Declare a national emergency!

Helen Redwood

“Never had it so good" claim some media pundits – this is definitely not true if you are trying to buy a house. 100% mortgages are now on offer and you might be able to "buy" a house, but you could be repaying the loan for 40 years, well into your retirement!

Gone are the days when young people could hope to have paid their mortgages off in their 40s or 50s. By the time you are finished paying back the bank, you will probably have paid for your house three times over. Someone taking out such a mortgage on a €375,000 three bedroom house will end up paying €750,000, and that’s only if interest rates remain at 4%. The EBS calculates that first time buyers will have poured €8.5 billion into companies in the housing market this year alone.

Only ten years ago, first time buyers could have bought a three bedroom semi-detached house for €69,350. Now they would have to fork out an average of €290,711, or €388,466 in Dublin. The ECB interest rate hike of 0.25% will add €56 a month to a €200,000 mortgage, and the predicted further rise of 0.5% by the end of the year will add over €100 to monthly repayments on a €250,000 mortgage.

In view of these price hikes, recent efforts by IBEC to blame wage increases for inflation ring ridiculously hollow. In fact the ratio between the average wage and the average house price is 11:1 and even wider in Dublin.

This is causing jitters amongst the parasites in the financial institutions who fear that such a disparity could lead to widespread defaulting on mortgages as prices and interest rates continue to rise. Some financial institutions warn that as many as 50,000 mortgage holders could find themselves in difficulty.

Already, first-time buyers can be spending up to a third of their income on mortgage repayments. This can only get worse as prices rise, yet lenders are throwing credit at people at the highest rate ever in the last five years.

However, another spectre hovers. As long as prices spiral exponentially away from the real construction costs, the prospect of the bubble bursting looms. Thousands of new buyers could be left in negative equity where the value of their house drops below what they paid for it.

A further consequence would be large job losses in construction. RTE economist George Lee has said that the basis of the boom in the economy has changed from previously being fuelled mainly by foreign direct investment, to now being dependent on the construction boom.

Public Housing - not Private Profiteering

Under fire about soaring house prices, the government has retaliated with statements that it intends to spend €1 billion on various social housing schemes, including the on-going work on 7.600 social housing units and the construction or acquisition of an extra 6,000 units.

A quick comparison with the hard facts reveals these promises to be a whitewash over an appalling lack of intention to seriously tackle the housing crisis.

The National Development Plan proposed 35,000 social and affordable houses to be completed this year, yet only 5,000 will come on stream. This represents a tiny proportion of the 81,000 houses built last year, the majority of which will have been sold in the private sector and out of reach for thousands of people.

In the meantime €1.63 billion of taxpayers’ money is being handed over in rent supplements to private landlords eager to take advantage of the 43,684 families on council waiting lists. This figure is about equivalent to the number of households in Cork City! That 40% of tenants in the private rented sector are on housing benefit shows the extent of the public subsidy enjoyed by private landlords. In reality the government is involved in a form of privatisation by stealth of people’s social housing needs.

Any serious attempt to tackle house prices and the massive social housing crisis means tackling the land speculators, developers and financial institutions. The Socialist Party believes that an emergency social housing programme is required to end the waiting lists and that through the nationalisation of the banks and financial institutions, people can be given cheap credit to allow them to purchase their own homes.

For a socialist housing policy

• Compulsory purchase of land by local authorities at agricultural prices to build up land banks for an emergency social housing building programme.

• Public ownership under democratic workers’ control & management of construction companies and financial institutions in order to:

a) Bring down prices and allow re-investment in a massive public house building scheme for low cost rent/purchase;

b) Enable the redirection of €1.63 billion of taxpayers’ money from subsidising private landlords into public housing

c) Ensure decent wages and conditions for construction & allied trades workers.


Tallaght town centre
A gift for property speculators

Cllr. Mick Murphy

Planning permission has been given for mixed commercial and residential development in Tallaght that includes 2,800 apartments.

Planning permission for all of this development was done while the Section 23 tax incentive was still in place and in these cases almost all the apartments are bought by speculators and are rented out.

With average tenure of less than one year in the private rental market, there is no prospect of a stable community developing under these conditions in Tallaght.

At a meeting in February the Council voted 25 for and myself against transferring Council land in the centre of Tallaght to develop the "Millenium Square Project" which included 413 section 23 apartments. I argued that while the project had some merit, they should at the very least wait as the project was about to loose its section 23 status two weeks later as then there might be some chance of young first time buyers affording them. Section 23 status can add €100,000 to the price of a property.

I also argued against re-zoning a one square mile area of the town centre which allows for the building of a further 3,000 apartments. A public meeting and coverage in the local media has helped rally opposition to the Council’s plan. Subsequently 100 submissions opposing the Council have been lodged by individuals and organisations.

The Council’s plan is a gift for builders and property speculators and the Socialist Party will continue to build opposition, aiming to force the Council to develop Tallaght for the needs of the community not the profits of the already obscenely rich.